December 10, 2018

“Independent” Medical Exams Scheduled by the Insurance Company are Rarely Legitimate

Funny Doctor breaks the bad newsA very common tactic used by workers’compensation insurance companies to cut off your benefits involves the use of something called an “independent medical exam” or IME.  As you might guess, in my experience these medical evaluations are rarely independent and they often serve no purpose other than medical support for termination of benefits.

Fortunately, most of the State Board judges that consider workers’ comp issues understand how the IME game works, and they look at these results with a very critical eye, but insurance adjusters continue to use this practice as a matter of course.

When I get an IME notice, the first thing I will look for is the name of the examining doctor.  There are a number of physicians out there who work extensively for the insurance industry and in almost every file sent to one of these doctors, the resulting report will minimize the extent and nature of the work injury, question the relation of injury to the accident at work , and suggest that a full duty return to work is appropriate.

Because the insurance company has the right to send you out for one of these biased IMEs, you have no choice but to go.  I can usually predict what the forthcoming report will say and that the insurance company is planning to try to cut you off, so I gear up to request a hearing challenging the proposed cut off.

The file will end up on the desk of a defense lawyer who I most likely know.  He or she and I will talk and acknowledge that the insurance IME was a waste of time and we will either start to discuss settlement, or try to agree on a more unbiased doctor to see you. [Read more…]

Do Not Expect Respect from the Insurance Company

insurance company bad faithI tend to write a lot about bad behavior by insurance companies and why you should not try to represent yourself in your workers’ compensation case.  Obviously I hope that you will consider Ginsberg Law Offices for your case but however you proceed, I hope that you understand clearly that you cannot and should not assume that the insurance company will act in good faith.

Just the other day, I received a letter in the mail in one of my cases stating that the insurance company had scheduled my client for an “independent” medical examination with a physician in Atlanta.  The problem is that my client lives over 150 miles away.

I got on the phone with opposing counsel and demanded to know why his client had scheduled this exam when there were numerous specialists located within 5 miles, 10 miles, 25 miles, etc. from where my client lives.  Obviously what’s going on here is that the insurance company knows that the Atlanta doctor will give them a report they want and they have no interest in finding out what is really going on with my client.

Opposing counsel said that his hands were tied so I requested a conference call with the judge.  During this call I restated my objection to this farce and accused the insurance company of acting in bad faith.  The judge felt that the insurance company had the right to choose a physician of its choice for the IME but he did order the insurance company to provide round trip transportation for my client. [Read more…]

Am I Entitled to More than One Independent Medical Exam if I have Multiple Work Injuries?

posted panel of physiciansUnder Georgia’s workers’ compensation law, your employer gets to direct where you get medical care if your employer provides you with a valid “posted panel of physicians.”   Not surprisingly, posted panel doctors sometimes bring a pro-employer bias to their treatment of you.  I regularly see – and you have no doubt heard stories about – cases in which a seriously injured man or woman is given a regular duty return to work, only to end up in surgery a few weeks later.

In 1990, the Georgia legislature gave injured workers an important new right, the “claimant’s IME (independent medical exam).  Under this law, an injured worker can request an independent medical examination with a doctor of his choosing, paid for by the employer’s insurance company.

When properly used as part of a effective claim strategy, your claimant’s IME can be used to:

  • refute the unfair and biased claim of industrial clinic doctors
  • contest a premature return to work demand by the insurance adjuster
  • support a request for a change in authorized treating physician
  • support a reasonable settlement demand

However, as important and valuable as your claimant’s IME rights may be, this right is not open ended and it can be wasted if not used properly. [Read more…]